ohi logo
OHI Science | Citation policy

[REFERENCE RMD FILE: https://cdn.rawgit.com/OHI-Science/ohiprep/master/globalprep/mar/v2017/mar_dataprep.html]

1 Summary

This analysis converts FAO mariculture data into data used to calculate the OHI global mariculture status score. This also calculates the genetic escapee from mariculture pressure data.

2 Updates from previous assessment

New year of FAO mariculture yield data, but no changes to sustainability or genetic escapee data or general methods.

A few small corrections to make sure the FAO_species fields matched in the species_list and Trujillo data.


3 Data Source

Reference:
http://www.fao.org/fishery/statistics/software/fishstatj/en#downlApp Release date: July 2017 FAO Global Aquaculture Production Quantity 1950_2014

Downloaded: 8/10/2017

Description: Quantity (tonnes) of mariculture for each county, species, year.

Time range: 1950-2015


4 Methods

# load libraries, set directories
library(ohicore)  #devtools::install_github('ohi-science/ohicore@dev')
library(dplyr)
## 
## Attaching package: 'dplyr'
## The following objects are masked from 'package:stats':
## 
##     filter, lag
## The following objects are masked from 'package:base':
## 
##     intersect, setdiff, setequal, union
library(stringr)
library(tidyr)

## comment out when knitting
#setwd("globalprep/mar/v2017")


### Load FAO-specific user-defined functions
source('mar_fxs.R') # functions specific to mariculture dealing with compound countries
source('../../../src/R/fao_fxn.R') # function for cleaning FAO files
source('../../../src/R/common.R') # directory locations

5 FAO Mariculuture data

Clean mariculture data: Filter freshwater mariculture, make long format, and clean FAO codes.

mar <- read.csv(file.path(dir_M, 'git-annex/globalprep/_raw_data/FAO_mariculture/d2017/FAO_GlobalAquacultureProduction_Quantity_1950_2015.csv'), check.names=FALSE, stringsAsFactors=FALSE) ; head(mar) 
##   Country (Country) Species (ASFIS species)
## 1       Afghanistan           Cyprinids nei
## 2       Afghanistan           Rainbow trout
## 3           Albania            Bighead carp
## 4           Albania             Common carp
## 5           Albania            Crucian carp
## 6           Albania        European seabass
##   Aquaculture area (FAO major fishing area) Environment (Environment) Unit
## 1                      Asia - Inland waters                Freshwater    t
## 2                      Asia - Inland waters                Freshwater    t
## 3                    Europe - Inland waters                Freshwater    t
## 4                    Europe - Inland waters                Freshwater    t
## 5                    Europe - Inland waters                Freshwater    t
## 6               Mediterranean and Black Sea                    Marine    t
##   1950 1951 1952 1953 1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 1959 1960 1961 1962 1963
## 1  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...
## 2  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...
## 3    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -
## 4  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...
## 5  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...
## 6  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...
##   1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975  1976  1977
## 1  ...  ...  ...  ...  ... 50 F 50 F 50 F 50 F 50 F 50 F 50 F 150 F 150 F
## 2  ...  ...  ...  ...  ... 10 F 10 F 10 F 10 F 10 F 10 F 10 F  20 F  20 F
## 3    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -    -     -     -
## 4  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...   ...   ...
## 5  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...   ...   ...
## 6  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...  ...   ...   ...
##    1978  1979  1980  1981  1982  1983  1984  1985  1986  1987  1988  1989
## 1 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F
## 2  20 F  20 F  20 F  20 F  20 F  20 F  20 F  20 F  20 F  20 F  20 F  20 F
## 3     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -
## 4   ...   ...   ...   ...   4 F  10 F    10    20    48    42    62   126
## 5   ...   ...   ...   1 F   6 F   8 F    10    10    12     5     2     7
## 6   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...
##    1990  1991  1992  1993  1994  1995  1996  1997  1998  1999  2000  2001
## 1 300 F 300 F 300 F 300 F 300 F 300 F 300 F 300 F 300 F 300 F 300 F 400 F
## 2   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...  50 F
## 3     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -
## 4  76 F  23 F  13 F  13 F  14 F  34 F  45 F     4     4     2     2     3
## 5   5 F   2 F   1 F   2 F   1 F     -     -     -     -     -     -     -
## 6   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...   ...
##    2002  2003  2004  2005  2006  2007  2008  2009  2010  2011  2012  2013
## 1 400 F 400 F 400 F 400 F 400 F 900 F 900 F 900 F 900 F 900 F 900 F 900 F
## 2  50 F  50 F  50 F  50 F  50 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F 150 F
## 3     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -
## 4     4     6     8     6    10    10    74     6     6     8   222 200 F
## 5     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -     -
## 6   ...   ...   ...   ...    87    84   142   135   135   170   170 170 F
##    2014   2015
## 1 950 F 1000 F
## 2 150 F  150 F
## 3     -     16
## 4   214   26.8
## 5     -     12
## 6 129.4    392
# mar <- read.csv('D:/git-annex/globalprep/_raw_data/FAO_mariculture/d2017/FAO_GlobalAquacultureProduction_Quantity_1950_2015.csv', check.names=FALSE, stringsAsFactors=FALSE) ; head(mar) 

mar <- mar %>%
  rename(country = `Country (Country)`,
         FAO_name = `Species (ASFIS species)`,
         fao = `Aquaculture area (FAO major fishing area)`,
         environment = `Environment (Environment)`)
table(mar$environment)  
## 
## Brackishwater    Freshwater        Marine 
##           491          1722          1041
# include only marine environments
mar <- mar %>%
filter(environment %in% c("Brackishwater", "Marine"))  

## long format and clean FAO codes:
mar <- mar %>%
  select(-Unit) 

## for some reason, I can't provide the data range in gather programatically!
col_num <- ncol(data.frame(mar))
range <- 5:col_num
mar <- mar %>%
  gather(key="year", value="value", 5:70) %>%
    fao_clean_data() 

Update species names and exclude non-food species. I simplified the species_list. I cut the “species”" name columns because it wasn’t clear what this was trying to accomplish and created potential error.

mar_sp <- read.csv('raw/species_list.csv', stringsAsFactors=FALSE) %>%
  select(FAO_name, exclude, alias, Taxon_code)
new.spp <- setdiff(mar$FAO_name, mar_sp$FAO_name)
new.spp # check: if dim has 0 rows it means all match
## character(0)
# if length(new.spp) >0 , hand check whether to keep (exclude seaweeds and species harvested for ornamental/medicinal), check if synonyms match Trujillo names

# Remove species not relevant to mariculuture goal (i.e., non-food species)
mar <- left_join (mar, mar_sp, by="FAO_name") 
mar <- filter (mar, exclude==0) 


# change names using species name and the species alias (global changes)
mar$species <- ifelse(!is.na(mar$alias), mar$alias, mar$FAO_name) 

# sum duplicates after name change (this also gets rid of the NA values)
mar <- mar %>%
  filter(!is.na(value)) %>%
  group_by(country, fao, environment, species, year, Taxon_code) %>%
    summarize(value = sum(value)) %>% 
  ungroup()


# eliminate time-series with all 0s
mar <- mar %>%
  group_by(country, species) %>%
  mutate(total_value = sum(value)) %>%
  filter(total_value > 0) %>%
  select(-total_value) %>%
  ungroup()

Convert country names to OHI regions

# Divide mariculture from countries that we report as separate regions (assume equal production in all regions)
# Netherlands Antilles: Conch restoration among Aruba, Bonaire, Curacao
# Channel Islands: Jersey and Guernsey
# Bonaire/S.Eustatius/Saba
# Yugoslavia SFR: no longer a country after 1992

mar <- mar %>%
  mutate(country = ifelse(country=="R\xe9union", "Reunion", country)) %>%  # this one is hard to get right
  mar_split()  # function in mar_fxs.R

mar_rgn <- name_2_rgn(df_in = mar, 
                       fld_name='country', 
                       flds_unique=c('species', 'fao', 'environment', 'Taxon_code', 'year'))
## 
## These data were removed for not having any match in the lookup tables:
## 
## Yugoslavia SFR 
##              1 
## 
## These data were removed for not being of the proper rgn_type (eez,ohi_region) or mismatching region names in the lookup tables:
##                          tmp_type
## tmp_name                  disputed
##   Palestine, Occupied Tr.        9
## 
## DUPLICATES found. Consider using collapse2rgn to collapse duplicates (function in progress).
## # A tibble: 15 x 1
##                     country
##                       <chr>
##  1                    Aruba
##  2                  Bonaire
##  3                    China
##  4     China, Hong Kong SAR
##  5                  Curacao
##  6               Guadeloupe
##  7                     Guam
##  8               Martinique
##  9               Montenegro
## 10     Northern Mariana Is.
## 11       Russian Federation
## 12    Serbia and Montenegro
## 13 Tanzania, United Rep. of
## 14       Un. Sov. Soc. Rep.
## 15                 Zanzibar
### sum values of regions with multiple subregions
mar_rgn <- mar_rgn %>%
  group_by(fao, environment, species, year, Taxon_code, rgn_id) %>%
  summarize(value = sum(value)) %>%
  ungroup()

data.frame(filter(mar_rgn, rgn_id==130) %>%
  filter(year==2013) %>%
  arrange(species))
##                        fao   environment                species year
## 1 Pacific, Eastern Central        Marine Natantian decapods nei 2013
## 2 Pacific, Eastern Central Brackishwater  Pacific cupped oyster 2013
## 3 Pacific, Eastern Central Brackishwater   Spotted rose snapper 2013
## 4 Pacific, Eastern Central Brackishwater        Whiteleg shrimp 2013
##   Taxon_code rgn_id value
## 1      CRUST    130     0
## 2         BI    130    20
## 3          F    130   180
## 4         SH    130  2890

For some regions, a specific species can be altered so that it matches more general Trujillo sustainability data. In this case, I don’t want the name changes to be global because some regions may have more specific species data.

(Will explore this in the future, but will not implement this year).

# ## based on looking at the list, make a few name changes to match the regions Trujillo data
# # Chile name modification
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==224 & mar_rgn$species == "Red abalone"] <- "Abalones nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==224 & mar_rgn$species == "Japanese abalone"] <- "Abalones nei"
# 
# # China
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==209 & mar_rgn$species == "Areolate grouper"] <- "Groupers nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==209 & mar_rgn$species == "Greasy grouper"] <- "Groupers nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==209 & mar_rgn$species == "Hong Kong grouper"] <- "Groupers nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==209 & mar_rgn$species == "Orange-spotted grouper"] <- "Groupers nei"
# 
# # Honduras
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==133 & mar_rgn$species == "Whiteleg shrimp"] <- "Penaeus shrimps nei"
# 
# # Italy
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==84 & mar_rgn$species == "Pacific cupped oyster"] <- "Cupped oysters nei"
# 
# # New Zealand
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==162 & mar_rgn$species == "Rainbow abalone"] <- "Abalones nei"
# 
# # Pakistan
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==53 & mar_rgn$species == "Penaeus shrimps nei"] <- "Marine crustaceans nei"
# 
# # Philippines
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==15 & mar_rgn$species == "Whiteleg shrimp"] <- "Penaeus shrimps nei"
# 
# # Portugal
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==183 & mar_rgn$species == "Golden carpet shell"] <- "Marine molluscs nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==183 & mar_rgn$species == "Peppery furrow"] <- "Marine molluscs nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==183 & mar_rgn$species == "Solen razor clams nei"] <- "Razor clams nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==183 & mar_rgn$species == "Atlantic bluefin tuna"] <- "Marine fishes nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==183 & mar_rgn$species == "Meagre"] <- "Marine fishes nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==183 & mar_rgn$species == "Seabasses nei"] <- "Marine fishes nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==183 & mar_rgn$species == "Soles nei"] <- "Marine fishes nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==183 & mar_rgn$species == "White seabream"] <- "Marine fishes nei"
# 
# # Spain
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==182 & mar_rgn$species == "Atlantic bluefin tuna"] <- "Tuna-like fishes nei"
# 
# # Turkey
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==76 & mar_rgn$species == "Atlantic bluefin tuna"] <- "Tuna-like fishes nei"
# mar_rgn$species[mar_rgn$rgn_id==76 & mar_rgn$species == "European seabass"] <- "Seabasses nei"
# 
# ### sum values of regions with multiple subregions
# mar_rgn <- mar_rgn %>%
#   group_by(fao, environment, species, year, Taxon_code, rgn_id) %>%
#   summarize(value = sum(value)) %>%
#   ungroup()

5.0.1 Gapfilling

Fill in missing years after first harvest with 0 values

mar_rgn_spread <- spread(mar_rgn, year, value)
dim(mar_rgn_spread)
## [1] 1301   71
mar_rgn_gf <- gather(mar_rgn_spread, "year", "value", 6:71) %>%
  arrange(rgn_id, species, year, Taxon_code, fao, environment)

## NA values are converted to zero.  I checked to make sure there 
## weren't instances in which in made more sense to carry the previous
## years data forward as a method of gapfilling. This didn't seem to be the case
mar_rgn_gf <- mar_rgn_gf %>%
  mutate(year = as.numeric(as.character(year))) %>%
  mutate(value_w_0 = ifelse(is.na(value), 0, value)) %>%
  group_by(fao, environment, species, Taxon_code, rgn_id) %>%
  mutate(cum_value = cumsum(value_w_0)) %>%
  ungroup() %>%
  filter(cum_value > 0) %>%
  mutate(gap_0_fill = ifelse(is.na(value), "NA_to_zero", "0")) %>%
  mutate(value = ifelse(is.na(value), 0, value)) %>%
  select(-cum_value, -value_w_0)
table(mar_rgn_gf$gap_0_fill)
## 
##          0 NA_to_zero 
##      25842       3344
## 3344 of these out of 25842+3344 cases

Remove time series with less than four non-zero datapoints (assume these are not established mariculture programs).

mar_rgn_gf = mar_rgn_gf %>% 
  group_by(rgn_id, species, fao, environment) %>%
  mutate (not_0 = length(value[value>0])) %>% 
  filter (not_0>3) %>%
  ungroup() %>% 
  select(rgn_id, species, fao, environment, year, value, Taxon_code, gap_0_fill)

Add a unique identifier per cultivated stock that describes species, fao region, and environment.

# add a unique identifier per cultivated stock
identifier = mar_rgn_gf %>% 
  select(rgn_id, species, fao, environment) %>% 
  unique() %>% 
  mutate(species_code = 1:n())

mar_rgn_gf = left_join(mar_rgn_gf, identifier)
## Joining, by = c("rgn_id", "species", "fao", "environment")
maric <- mar_rgn_gf

Save file to estimate total mariculture yield per country.

write.csv(maric, 'output/MAR_FP_data.csv', row.names=FALSE)

6 Trujillo sustainability scores

These data describe the sustainability and genetic escapes for country/species combinations (and, in a couple cases, environment and fao region combinations). In cases where these data were not available for a specific county/species, we averaged the data across taxonomic groups to gapfill the missing data.

Convert country names to OHI region names.

# Trujillo sustainability data:
sus = read.csv('raw/Truj_label_sust.csv', stringsAsFactors = FALSE, na.strings = NA)

## these need to be re-added (get cut when associated with region ids)
sus_no_rgn <- filter(sus, is.na(country))

# convert country names to OHI region names:
sus_rgn <- name_2_rgn(df_in = sus, 
                       fld_name='country', 
                       flds_unique=c('species_fao', 'fao', 'environment', 'species_Truj'))
## 
## These data were removed for not having any match in the lookup tables:
## < table of extent 0 >
sus_rgn <- bind_rows(sus_rgn, sus_no_rgn) %>%
  unique()


# check the fao spp list in the Trujillo sustainability file matches FAO mariculture species
setdiff(sus_rgn$species_fao, maric$species) # species that are no longer have mariculture industry or are not included due to being freshwater or non-food
##  [1] "River Plata mussel"    "Gracilaria seaweeds"  
##  [3] "Laver (Nori)"          "Atlantic wolffish"    
##  [5] "Spotted wolffish"      "Bagrid catfish"       
##  [7] "Freshwater fishes nei" "Tilapias nei"         
##  [9] "Torpedo catfishes nei" "Brill"                
## [11] "Razor clams nei"       "Brown seaweeds"       
## [13] "Brown seaweeds (Pac)"  "Silver carp"          
## [15] "Sturgeons nei"         "Blackchin tilapia"    
## [17] "Giant river prawn"     "Nile tilapia"         
## [19] "Aquatic plants nei"    "Tuna-like fishes nei" 
## [21] "Algae & marine plants" "All others"           
## [23] "Bivalve & gastropod"   "Blue tilapia"         
## [25] "Cephalopod"            "Crabs and lobsters"   
## [27] "Eucheuma seaweeds nei" "Fish"                 
## [29] "Importo totale"        "Inverts"              
## [31] "Japanese kelp"         "Molluscs"             
## [33] "Mozambique tilapia"    "Non-crustacean invert"
## [35] "Nori nei"              "Shrimp & prawn"       
## [37] "Spiny eucheuma"        "Trouts nei"           
## [39] "Tunicate"              "Urchin"               
## [41] "Wakame"                "Warty gracilaria"
sort(setdiff(maric$species, sus_rgn$species_fao)) # species with no Trujillo data
##   [1] "Akiami paste shrimp"            "Amberjacks nei"                
##   [3] "Anadara clams nei"              "Aquatic invertebrates nei"     
##   [5] "Areolate grouper"               "Atlantic ditch shrimp"         
##   [7] "Australian mussel"              "Banded carpet shell"           
##   [9] "Bastard halibut"                "Bastard halibuts nei"          
##  [11] "Bear paw clam"                  "Blackhead seabream"            
##  [13] "Blacklip pearl oyster"          "Blackspot(=red) seabream"      
##  [15] "blood cockle"                   "Blue crab"                     
##  [17] "Blue swimming crab"             "Brine shrimp"                  
##  [19] "Brown tiger prawn"              "Butter clam"                   
##  [21] "Caramote prawn"                 "Chars nei"                     
##  [23] "Chilean flat oyster"            "Chilean mussel"                
##  [25] "Cholga mussel"                  "Choro mussel"                  
##  [27] "Cobia"                          "Cockles nei"                   
##  [29] "Common dentex"                  "Common pandora"                
##  [31] "Common prawn"                   "Cortez oyster"                 
##  [33] "Crevalle jack"                  "Crimson seabream"              
##  [35] "Croakers, drums nei"            "Crocus giant clam"             
##  [37] "Donax clams"                    "Dotted gizzard shad"           
##  [39] "Drums nei"                      "Eastern king prawn"            
##  [41] "Eastern school shrimp"          "Elongate giant clam"           
##  [43] "European flounder"              "European whitefish"            
##  [45] "Filefishes, leatherjackets nei" "Filefishes nei"                
##  [47] "Finfishes nei"                  "Flathead lobster"              
##  [49] "Fleshy prawn"                   "Florida pompano"               
##  [51] "Fluted giant clam"              "Fourfinger threadfin"          
##  [53] "Gastropods nei"                 "Gazami crab"                   
##  [55] "Giant clam"                     "Giant clams nei"               
##  [57] "Globose clam"                   "Golden carpet shell"           
##  [59] "Golden trevally"                "Goldlined seabream"            
##  [61] "Goldsilk seabream"              "Greasy grouper"                
##  [63] "Great Atlantic scallop"         "Greater amberjack"             
##  [65] "Green crab"                     "Green tiger prawn"             
##  [67] "Groundfishes nei"               "Gudgeons, sleepers nei"        
##  [69] "Hong Kong grouper"              "Hooded oyster"                 
##  [71] "Horned turban"                  "Horse mussels nei"             
##  [73] "Humpback grouper"               "Indian backwater oyster"       
##  [75] "Indo-Pacific swamp crab"        "Inflated ark"                  
##  [77] "Jacks, crevalles nei"           "Japanese abalone"              
##  [79] "Japanese amberjack"             "Japanese eel"                  
##  [81] "Japanese hard clam"             "Japanese jack mackerel"        
##  [83] "Japanese meagre"                "Japanese seabass"              
##  [85] "Japanese sea cucumber"          "Japanese spiny lobster"        
##  [87] "Jellyfishes nei"                "Korean rockfish"               
##  [89] "Largemouth black bass"          "Large yellow croaker"          
##  [91] "Lebranche mullet"               "Lefteye flounders nei"         
##  [93] "Mackerels nei"                  "Malabar grouper"               
##  [95] "Mangrove cupped oyster"         "Marbled spinefoot"             
##  [97] "Marine crabs nei"               "Meagre"                        
##  [99] "Mud spiny lobster"              "Northern quahog(=Hard clam)"   
## [101] "Northern white shrimp"          "Octopuses, etc. nei"           
## [103] "Okhotsk atka mackerel"          "Olympia oyster"                
## [105] "Orange mud crab"                "Pacific bluefin tuna"          
## [107] "Pacific calico scallop"         "Pacific geoduck"               
## [109] "Pacific horse clam"             "Pacific lion's paw"            
## [111] "Pacific littleneck clam"        "Palaemonid shrimps nei"        
## [113] "Papuan black snapper"           "Pargo breams nei"              
## [115] "Pearl oyster shells nei"        "Penguin wing oyster"           
## [117] "Pen shells nei"                 "Peppery furrow"                
## [119] "Periwinkles nei"                "Pod razor shell"               
## [121] "Pollack"                        "Porgies, seabreams nei"        
## [123] "Portunus swimcrabs nei"         "Puffers nei"                   
## [125] "Queen conch"                    "Queen scallop"                 
## [127] "Rainbow abalone"                "Red abalone"                   
## [129] "Red porgy"                      "Redtail prawn"                 
## [131] "Righteye flounders nei"         "Russell's snapper"             
## [133] "Salmonids nei"                  "Salmonoids nei"                
## [135] "Sand gaper"                     "Scats"                         
## [137] "Sciaenas nei"                   "Scorpionfishes nei"            
## [139] "Sea cucumbers nei"              "Sea snails"                    
## [141] "Sea squirts nei"                "Senegalese sole"               
## [143] "Sharpsnout seabream"            "Shi drum"                      
## [145] "Sixfinger threadfin"            "Slipper cupped oyster"         
## [147] "Smooth giant clam"              "Snappers, jobfishes nei"       
## [149] "Snooks(=Robalos) nei"           "Snubnose pompano"              
## [151] "Sobaity seabream"               "[Solea spp]"                   
## [153] "Solen razor clams nei"          "Soles nei"                     
## [155] "South American rock mussel"     "Southern Australia scallop"    
## [157] "Southern white shrimp"          "Speckled shrimp"               
## [159] "Spiny lobsters nei"             "Spotted rose snapper"          
## [161] "Spotted seabass"                "Squaretail mullet"             
## [163] "Stony sea urchin"               "Streaked spinefoot"            
## [165] "Striped bass, hybrid"           "Stromboid conchs nei"          
## [167] "Sydney cupped oyster"           "Thinlip grey mullet"           
## [169] "Tropical spiny lobsters nei"    "Trumpet emperor"               
## [171] "Variegated scallop"             "Venus clams nei"               
## [173] "Warty venus"                    "Whitemouth croaker"            
## [175] "White seabream"                 "White-spotted spinefoot"       
## [177] "White trevally"                 "Yellowfin seabream"

7 FAO maricultue and sustainability scores

Match the sustainability score to the FAO mariculture data.

The following joins the sustainability scores to regions/species that have Trujillo data.

table(sus_rgn$match_type)
## 
##     c_sp c_sp_env c_sp_fao  species    taxon 
##      301        4        2      110       12
# join taxa specific to country/species/environment
c_sp_env = sus_rgn %>% 
  filter(match_type == 'c_sp_env') %>% 
  select(rgn_id, species=species_fao, environment, Sust_c_sp_env = Maric_sustainability)

mar_sus <- maric %>%
  left_join(c_sp_env, by= c("species", "environment", "rgn_id"))

# join taxa specific to country/species/fao region
c_sp_fao = sus_rgn %>% 
  filter(match_type == 'c_sp_fao') %>% 
  select(rgn_id, species=species_fao, fao, Sust_c_sp_fao = Maric_sustainability)

mar_sus <- mar_sus %>%
  left_join(c_sp_fao, by= c("species", "fao", "rgn_id"))

data.frame(filter(mar_sus, rgn_id==218 & species == "Atlantic salmon"))
##    rgn_id         species                 fao environment year value
## 1     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1979     5
## 2     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1980    27
## 3     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1981    76
## 4     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1982   143
## 5     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1983    68
## 6     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1984   222
## 7     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1985   349
## 8     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1986   682
## 9     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1987  1382
## 10    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1987     3
## 11    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1988  3351
## 12    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1988    80
## 13    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1989  4687
## 14    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1989  1280
## 15    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1990  7835
## 16    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1990  1790
## 17    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1991  9848
## 18    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1991  3651
## 19    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1992 10520
## 20    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1992  6785
## 21    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1993 11123
## 22    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1993 12360
## 23    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1994 12426
## 24    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1994 15347
## 25    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1995 15235
## 26    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1995 18439
## 27    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1996 17800
## 28    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1996 18675
## 29    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1997 20310
## 30    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1997 30705
## 31    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1998 16418
## 32    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1998 33057
## 33    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1999 23190
## 34    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1999 38800
## 35    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2000 33195
## 36    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2000 39300
## 37    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2001 37606
## 38    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2001 58000
## 39    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2002 42121
## 40    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2002 72800
## 41    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2003 34550
## 42    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2003 72678
## 43    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2004 35000
## 44    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2004 61774
## 45    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2005 35000
## 46    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2005 63370
## 47    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2006 47880
## 48    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2006 70181
## 49    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2007 31511
## 50    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2007 70998
## 51    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2008 30810
## 52    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2008 73265
## 53    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2009 31550
## 54    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2009 68662
## 55    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2010 30713
## 56    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2010 70831
## 57    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2011 27184
## 58    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2011 83144
## 59    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2012 36120
## 60    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2012 79981
## 61    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2013 25453
## 62    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2013 72176
## 63    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2014 23872
## 64    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2014 62475
## 65    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2015 29000
## 66    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2015 92926
##    Taxon_code gap_0_fill species_code Sust_c_sp_env Sust_c_sp_fao
## 1           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 2           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 3           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 4           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 5           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 6           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 7           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 8           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 9           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 10          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 11          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 12          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 13          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 14          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 15          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 16          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 17          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 18          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 19          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 20          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 21          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 22          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 23          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 24          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 25          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 26          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 27          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 28          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 29          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 30          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 31          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 32          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 33          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 34          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 35          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 36          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 37          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 38          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 39          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 40          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 41          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 42          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 43          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 44          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 45          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 46          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 47          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 48          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 49          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 50          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 51          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 52          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 53          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 54          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 55          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 56          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 57          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 58          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 59          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 60          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 61          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 62          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 63          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 64          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 65          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 66          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
data.frame(filter(mar_sus, !is.na(Sust_c_sp_fao)))
##    rgn_id         species                 fao environment year value
## 1     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1979     5
## 2     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1980    27
## 3     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1981    76
## 4     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1982   143
## 5     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1983    68
## 6     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1984   222
## 7     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1985   349
## 8     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1986   682
## 9     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1987  1382
## 10    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1987     3
## 11    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1988  3351
## 12    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1988    80
## 13    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1989  4687
## 14    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1989  1280
## 15    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1990  7835
## 16    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1990  1790
## 17    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1991  9848
## 18    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1991  3651
## 19    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1992 10520
## 20    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1992  6785
## 21    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1993 11123
## 22    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1993 12360
## 23    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1994 12426
## 24    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1994 15347
## 25    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1995 15235
## 26    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1995 18439
## 27    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1996 17800
## 28    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1996 18675
## 29    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1997 20310
## 30    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1997 30705
## 31    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1998 16418
## 32    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1998 33057
## 33    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1999 23190
## 34    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1999 38800
## 35    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2000 33195
## 36    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2000 39300
## 37    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2001 37606
## 38    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2001 58000
## 39    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2002 42121
## 40    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2002 72800
## 41    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2003 34550
## 42    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2003 72678
## 43    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2004 35000
## 44    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2004 61774
## 45    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2005 35000
## 46    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2005 63370
## 47    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2006 47880
## 48    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2006 70181
## 49    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2007 31511
## 50    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2007 70998
## 51    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2008 30810
## 52    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2008 73265
## 53    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2009 31550
## 54    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2009 68662
## 55    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2010 30713
## 56    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2010 70831
## 57    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2011 27184
## 58    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2011 83144
## 59    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2012 36120
## 60    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2012 79981
## 61    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2013 25453
## 62    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2013 72176
## 63    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2014 23872
## 64    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2014 62475
## 65    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2015 29000
## 66    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2015 92926
##    Taxon_code gap_0_fill species_code Sust_c_sp_env Sust_c_sp_fao
## 1           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 2           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 3           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 4           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 5           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 6           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 7           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 8           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 9           F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 10          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 11          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 12          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 13          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 14          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 15          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 16          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 17          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 18          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 19          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 20          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 21          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 22          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 23          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 24          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 25          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 26          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 27          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 28          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 29          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 30          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 31          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 32          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 33          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 34          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 35          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 36          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 37          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 38          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 39          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 40          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 41          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 42          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 43          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 44          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 45          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 46          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 47          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 48          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 49          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 50          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 51          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 52          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 53          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 54          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 55          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 56          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 57          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 58          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 59          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 60          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 61          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 62          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 63          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 64          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
## 65          F          0         1004            NA          0.17
## 66          F          0         1005            NA          0.27
# join taxa specific to country/species
c_sp = sus_rgn %>% 
  filter(match_type == 'c_sp') %>% 
  select(rgn_id, species=species_fao, Sust_c_sp = Maric_sustainability)

mar_sus <- mar_sus %>%
  left_join(c_sp, by= c("species", "rgn_id"))
summary(mar_sus)
##      rgn_id        species              fao            environment       
##  Min.   :  5.0   Length:27001       Length:27001       Length:27001      
##  1st Qu.: 51.0   Class :character   Class :character   Class :character  
##  Median :163.0   Mode  :character   Mode  :character   Mode  :character  
##  Mean   :130.3                                                           
##  3rd Qu.:205.0                                                           
##  Max.   :250.0                                                           
##                                                                          
##       year          value          Taxon_code         gap_0_fill       
##  Min.   :1950   Min.   :      0   Length:27001       Length:27001      
##  1st Qu.:1991   1st Qu.:      1   Class :character   Class :character  
##  Median :2002   Median :     97   Mode  :character   Mode  :character  
##  Mean   :1998   Mean   :  17348                                        
##  3rd Qu.:2009   3rd Qu.:   1818                                        
##  Max.   :2015   Max.   :4573953                                        
##                                                                        
##   species_code    Sust_c_sp_env   Sust_c_sp_fao     Sust_c_sp    
##  Min.   :   1.0   Min.   :0.170   Min.   :0.170   Min.   :0.100  
##  1st Qu.: 246.0   1st Qu.:0.170   1st Qu.:0.170   1st Qu.:0.330  
##  Median : 537.0   Median :0.230   Median :0.170   Median :0.470  
##  Mean   : 536.2   Mean   :0.231   Mean   :0.214   Mean   :0.521  
##  3rd Qu.: 833.0   3rd Qu.:0.270   3rd Qu.:0.270   3rd Qu.:0.770  
##  Max.   :1068.0   Max.   :0.270   Max.   :0.270   Max.   :1.000  
##                   NA's   :26911   NA's   :26935   NA's   :17238
### merge these into a single sustainability score
mar_sus = mar_sus %>% 
  mutate(Sust = ifelse(!is.na(Sust_c_sp_env), Sust_c_sp_env, Sust_c_sp_fao)) %>%
  mutate(Sust = ifelse(is.na(Sust), Sust_c_sp, Sust)) %>%
  select(-Sust_c_sp_env, -Sust_c_sp_fao, -Sust_c_sp)

This joins the sustainability data that is gapfilled either at the species level (average of specific species/genera across regions) or at a higher course taxonomic levels and documents which data are gapfilled and how.

## Gapfilled at the species/genera level:
gf_sp_sus <- filter(sus_rgn, gapfill != "actuals" & match_type == "species") %>%
  select(species = species_fao, gapfill, Sust_gf_sp = Maric_sustainability)

## check that there are no duplicated species_fao
gf_sp_sus[duplicated(gf_sp_sus$species), ]
## [1] species    gapfill    Sust_gf_sp
## <0 rows> (or 0-length row.names)
# Match gapfilling values by species
mar_sus_gf = mar_sus %>%
  left_join(gf_sp_sus, by = 'species')


# Gapfilled at the coarse taxon level:
gf_taxon_sus <- filter(sus_rgn, gapfill != "actuals" & match_type == "taxon") %>%
  select(Taxon_code=taxon, Sust_gf_taxon = Maric_sustainability)

# Match gapfilling values by species
mar_sus_gf = mar_sus_gf %>%
  left_join(gf_taxon_sus, by = c('Taxon_code'))

summary(mar_sus_gf)
##      rgn_id        species              fao            environment       
##  Min.   :  5.0   Length:27001       Length:27001       Length:27001      
##  1st Qu.: 51.0   Class :character   Class :character   Class :character  
##  Median :163.0   Mode  :character   Mode  :character   Mode  :character  
##  Mean   :130.3                                                           
##  3rd Qu.:205.0                                                           
##  Max.   :250.0                                                           
##                                                                          
##       year          value          Taxon_code         gap_0_fill       
##  Min.   :1950   Min.   :      0   Length:27001       Length:27001      
##  1st Qu.:1991   1st Qu.:      1   Class :character   Class :character  
##  Median :2002   Median :     97   Mode  :character   Mode  :character  
##  Mean   :1998   Mean   :  17348                                        
##  3rd Qu.:2009   3rd Qu.:   1818                                        
##  Max.   :2015   Max.   :4573953                                        
##                                                                        
##   species_code         Sust         gapfill            Sust_gf_sp   
##  Min.   :   1.0   Min.   :0.100   Length:27001       Min.   :0.100  
##  1st Qu.: 246.0   1st Qu.:0.330   Class :character   1st Qu.:0.375  
##  Median : 537.0   Median :0.470   Mode  :character   Median :0.478  
##  Mean   : 536.2   Mean   :0.516                      Mean   :0.546  
##  3rd Qu.: 833.0   3rd Qu.:0.770                      3rd Qu.:0.757  
##  Max.   :1068.0   Max.   :1.000                      Max.   :0.902  
##                   NA's   :17082                      NA's   :8214   
##  Sust_gf_taxon   
##  Min.   :0.3667  
##  1st Qu.:0.4440  
##  Median :0.4440  
##  Mean   :0.5587  
##  3rd Qu.:0.8118  
##  Max.   :0.8118  
## 
table(mar_sus_gf$gapfill)
## 
## genus_average    sp_average 
##          2269         16518
#Obtain a sustainability score for each record, and a book-keeping column of whether it's actual or gap-filled
mar_sus_final = mar_sus_gf %>% 
  mutate(gapfill = ifelse(!is.na(Sust), "none", gapfill)) %>% 
  mutate(Sust = ifelse(is.na(Sust), Sust_gf_sp, Sust)) %>%
  mutate(gapfill = ifelse(is.na(Sust), "taxon_average", gapfill)) %>%
  mutate(Sust = ifelse(is.na(Sust), Sust_gf_taxon, Sust)) %>%
  mutate(taxa_code = paste(species, species_code, sep="_")) %>%
  select(rgn_id, species, species_code, taxa_code, year, gapfill_sus = gapfill, gapfill_fao = gap_0_fill, tonnes=value, Sust)


## save data layers
mar_harvest_tonnes = mar_sus_final %>%
  select(rgn_id, taxa_code, year, tonnes)
anyDuplicated(mar_harvest_tonnes)
## [1] 0
write.csv(mar_harvest_tonnes, 'output/mar_harvest_tonnes.csv', row.names=F)

mar_harvest_tonnes_gf = mar_sus_final %>%
  select(rgn_id, taxa_code, year, tonnes=gapfill_fao)
write.csv(mar_harvest_tonnes, 'output/mar_harvest_tonnes_gf.csv', row.names=F)


mar_sustainability_score = mar_sus_final %>% 
  mutate(year = 2012) %>%
  select(rgn_id, year, taxa_code, sust_coeff = Sust) %>% 
  unique()
anyDuplicated(mar_sustainability_score)
## [1] 0
write.csv(mar_sustainability_score, 'output/mar_sustainability.csv', row.names=F)

mar_sustainability_score_gf = mar_sus_final %>% 
  select(rgn_id, taxa_code, sust_coeff = gapfill_sus) %>% 
  unique()
write.csv(mar_sustainability_score, 'output/mar_sustainability_gf.csv', row.names=F)

8 Genetic escapes data

These data are used as a pressure layer to describe the risk of genetic escapees due to mariculture.

First merge with the species data (no gapfilling) for each country/species/fao region combination.

# can eliminate the environment category because these have the same scores
esc = sus_rgn %>% 
  filter(!is.na(Genetic.escapees)) %>%
  mutate(match_type = ifelse(match_type == "c_sp_env", "c_sp", match_type)) %>%
  group_by(rgn_id, species=species_fao, fao, match_type, taxon, gapfill) %>%
  summarize(Genetic.escapees = mean(Genetic.escapees)) %>%
  ungroup()
  
# join taxa specific to country/species/fao
c_sp_fao = esc %>% 
  filter(match_type == 'c_sp_fao') %>% 
  select(rgn_id, species, fao, Esc_c_sp_fao = Genetic.escapees) 

mar_esc <- maric %>%
  left_join(c_sp_fao, by= c("species", "fao", "rgn_id"))

data.frame(filter(mar_esc, !is.na(Esc_c_sp_fao)))
##    rgn_id         species                 fao environment year value
## 1     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1979     5
## 2     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1980    27
## 3     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1981    76
## 4     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1982   143
## 5     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1983    68
## 6     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1984   222
## 7     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1985   349
## 8     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1986   682
## 9     218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1987  1382
## 10    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1987     3
## 11    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1988  3351
## 12    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1988    80
## 13    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1989  4687
## 14    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1989  1280
## 15    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1990  7835
## 16    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1990  1790
## 17    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1991  9848
## 18    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1991  3651
## 19    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1992 10520
## 20    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1992  6785
## 21    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1993 11123
## 22    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1993 12360
## 23    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1994 12426
## 24    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1994 15347
## 25    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1995 15235
## 26    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1995 18439
## 27    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1996 17800
## 28    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1996 18675
## 29    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1997 20310
## 30    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1997 30705
## 31    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1998 16418
## 32    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1998 33057
## 33    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 1999 23190
## 34    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 1999 38800
## 35    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2000 33195
## 36    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2000 39300
## 37    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2001 37606
## 38    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2001 58000
## 39    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2002 42121
## 40    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2002 72800
## 41    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2003 34550
## 42    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2003 72678
## 43    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2004 35000
## 44    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2004 61774
## 45    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2005 35000
## 46    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2005 63370
## 47    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2006 47880
## 48    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2006 70181
## 49    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2007 31511
## 50    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2007 70998
## 51    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2008 30810
## 52    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2008 73265
## 53    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2009 31550
## 54    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2009 68662
## 55    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2010 30713
## 56    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2010 70831
## 57    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2011 27184
## 58    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2011 83144
## 59    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2012 36120
## 60    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2012 79981
## 61    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2013 25453
## 62    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2013 72176
## 63    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2014 23872
## 64    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2014 62475
## 65    218 Atlantic salmon Atlantic, Northwest      Marine 2015 29000
## 66    218 Atlantic salmon  Pacific, Northeast      Marine 2015 92926
##    Taxon_code gap_0_fill species_code Esc_c_sp_fao
## 1           F          0         1004          1.0
## 2           F          0         1004          1.0
## 3           F          0         1004          1.0
## 4           F          0         1004          1.0
## 5           F          0         1004          1.0
## 6           F          0         1004          1.0
## 7           F          0         1004          1.0
## 8           F          0         1004          1.0
## 9           F          0         1004          1.0
## 10          F          0         1005          0.1
## 11          F          0         1004          1.0
## 12          F          0         1005          0.1
## 13          F          0         1004          1.0
## 14          F          0         1005          0.1
## 15          F          0         1004          1.0
## 16          F          0         1005          0.1
## 17          F          0         1004          1.0
## 18          F          0         1005          0.1
## 19          F          0         1004          1.0
## 20          F          0         1005          0.1
## 21          F          0         1004          1.0
## 22          F          0         1005          0.1
## 23          F          0         1004          1.0
## 24          F          0         1005          0.1
## 25          F          0         1004          1.0
## 26          F          0         1005          0.1
## 27          F          0         1004          1.0
## 28          F          0         1005          0.1
## 29          F          0         1004          1.0
## 30          F          0         1005          0.1
## 31          F          0         1004          1.0
## 32          F          0         1005          0.1
## 33          F          0         1004          1.0
## 34          F          0         1005          0.1
## 35          F          0         1004          1.0
## 36          F          0         1005          0.1
## 37          F          0         1004          1.0
## 38          F          0         1005          0.1
## 39          F          0         1004          1.0
## 40          F          0         1005          0.1
## 41          F          0         1004          1.0
## 42          F          0         1005          0.1
## 43          F          0         1004          1.0
## 44          F          0         1005          0.1
## 45          F          0         1004          1.0
## 46          F          0         1005          0.1
## 47          F          0         1004          1.0
## 48          F          0         1005          0.1
## 49          F          0         1004          1.0
## 50          F          0         1005          0.1
## 51          F          0         1004          1.0
## 52          F          0         1005          0.1
## 53          F          0         1004          1.0
## 54          F          0         1005          0.1
## 55          F          0         1004          1.0
## 56          F          0         1005          0.1
## 57          F          0         1004          1.0
## 58          F          0         1005          0.1
## 59          F          0         1004          1.0
## 60          F          0         1005          0.1
## 61          F          0         1004          1.0
## 62          F          0         1005          0.1
## 63          F          0         1004          1.0
## 64          F          0         1005          0.1
## 65          F          0         1004          1.0
## 66          F          0         1005          0.1
# join taxa specific to country/species
c_sp = esc %>% 
  filter(match_type == 'c_sp') %>% 
  select(rgn_id, species, Esc_c_sp = Genetic.escapees)

mar_esc <- mar_esc %>%
  left_join(c_sp, by= c("species", "rgn_id"))
summary(mar_esc)
##      rgn_id        species              fao            environment       
##  Min.   :  5.0   Length:27001       Length:27001       Length:27001      
##  1st Qu.: 51.0   Class :character   Class :character   Class :character  
##  Median :163.0   Mode  :character   Mode  :character   Mode  :character  
##  Mean   :130.3                                                           
##  3rd Qu.:205.0                                                           
##  Max.   :250.0                                                           
##                                                                          
##       year          value          Taxon_code         gap_0_fill       
##  Min.   :1950   Min.   :      0   Length:27001       Length:27001      
##  1st Qu.:1991   1st Qu.:      1   Class :character   Class :character  
##  Median :2002   Median :     97   Mode  :character   Mode  :character  
##  Mean   :1998   Mean   :  17348                                        
##  3rd Qu.:2009   3rd Qu.:   1818                                        
##  Max.   :2015   Max.   :4573953                                        
##                                                                        
##   species_code     Esc_c_sp_fao      Esc_c_sp    
##  Min.   :   1.0   Min.   :0.100   Min.   :0.100  
##  1st Qu.: 246.0   1st Qu.:0.100   1st Qu.:0.500  
##  Median : 537.0   Median :1.000   Median :1.000  
##  Mean   : 536.2   Mean   :0.605   Mean   :0.739  
##  3rd Qu.: 833.0   3rd Qu.:1.000   3rd Qu.:1.000  
##  Max.   :1068.0   Max.   :1.000   Max.   :1.000  
##                   NA's   :26935   NA's   :17148
### merge these into a single sustainability score
mar_esc = mar_esc %>% 
  mutate(Escapees = ifelse(!is.na(Esc_c_sp_fao), Esc_c_sp_fao, Esc_c_sp)) %>%
  select(-Esc_c_sp_fao, -Esc_c_sp)

Join the sustainability data that is gapfilled either at the species level (average of specific species/genera across regions) or at a higher course taxonomic levels and documents which data are gapfilled and how.

## Gapfilled at the species/genera level:
gf_species_esc <- filter(esc, gapfill != "actuals" & match_type == "species") %>%
  select(species, gapfill, Esc_gf_sp = Genetic.escapees)

## check that there are no duplicated species_fao
gf_species_esc[duplicated(gf_species_esc$species), ]
## # A tibble: 0 x 3
## # ... with 3 variables: species <chr>, gapfill <chr>, Esc_gf_sp <dbl>
# Match gapfilling values by species
mar_esc_gf = mar_esc %>%
  left_join(gf_species_esc, by = 'species')


# Gapfilled at the coarse taxon level:
gf_taxon_sus <- filter(esc, gapfill != "actuals" & match_type == "taxon") %>%
  select(Taxon_code=taxon, Esc_gf_taxon = Genetic.escapees)

# Match gapfilling values by species
mar_esc_gf = mar_esc_gf %>%
  left_join(gf_taxon_sus, by = c('Taxon_code'))

summary(mar_esc_gf)
##      rgn_id        species              fao            environment       
##  Min.   :  5.0   Length:27001       Length:27001       Length:27001      
##  1st Qu.: 51.0   Class :character   Class :character   Class :character  
##  Median :163.0   Mode  :character   Mode  :character   Mode  :character  
##  Mean   :130.3                                                           
##  3rd Qu.:205.0                                                           
##  Max.   :250.0                                                           
##                                                                          
##       year          value          Taxon_code         gap_0_fill       
##  Min.   :1950   Min.   :      0   Length:27001       Length:27001      
##  1st Qu.:1991   1st Qu.:      1   Class :character   Class :character  
##  Median :2002   Median :     97   Mode  :character   Mode  :character  
##  Mean   :1998   Mean   :  17348                                        
##  3rd Qu.:2009   3rd Qu.:   1818                                        
##  Max.   :2015   Max.   :4573953                                        
##                                                                        
##   species_code       Escapees       gapfill            Esc_gf_sp    
##  Min.   :   1.0   Min.   :0.100   Length:27001       Min.   :0.500  
##  1st Qu.: 246.0   1st Qu.:0.500   Class :character   1st Qu.:0.500  
##  Median : 537.0   Median :1.000   Mode  :character   Median :0.625  
##  Mean   : 536.2   Mean   :0.738                      Mean   :0.678  
##  3rd Qu.: 833.0   3rd Qu.:1.000                      3rd Qu.:0.797  
##  Max.   :1068.0   Max.   :1.000                      Max.   :0.925  
##                   NA's   :17082                      NA's   :24732  
##   Esc_gf_taxon   
##  Min.   :0.1000  
##  1st Qu.:0.7423  
##  Median :0.7423  
##  Mean   :0.7045  
##  3rd Qu.:0.7664  
##  Max.   :0.7664  
## 
table(mar_esc_gf$gapfill)
## 
## genus_average 
##          2269
#Obtain a sustainability score for each record, and a book-keeping column of whether it's actual or gap-filled
tonnes_esc = mar_esc_gf %>% 
  mutate(gapfill = ifelse(!is.na(Escapees), "none", gapfill)) %>% 
  mutate(Escapees = ifelse(is.na(Escapees), Esc_gf_sp, Escapees)) %>%
  mutate(gapfill = ifelse(is.na(Escapees), "taxon_average", gapfill)) %>%
  mutate(Escapees = ifelse(is.na(Escapees), Esc_gf_taxon, Escapees)) %>%
  select(rgn_id, species, species_code, year, gapfill_escapees = gapfill, tonnes=value, Escapees)

summary(tonnes_esc)
##      rgn_id        species           species_code         year     
##  Min.   :  5.0   Length:27001       Min.   :   1.0   Min.   :1950  
##  1st Qu.: 51.0   Class :character   1st Qu.: 246.0   1st Qu.:1991  
##  Median :163.0   Mode  :character   Median : 537.0   Median :2002  
##  Mean   :130.3                      Mean   : 536.2   Mean   :1998  
##  3rd Qu.:205.0                      3rd Qu.: 833.0   3rd Qu.:2009  
##  Max.   :250.0                      Max.   :1068.0   Max.   :2015  
##  gapfill_escapees       tonnes           Escapees     
##  Length:27001       Min.   :      0   Min.   :0.1000  
##  Class :character   1st Qu.:      1   1st Qu.:0.5807  
##  Mode  :character   Median :     97   Median :0.7664  
##                     Mean   :  17348   Mean   :0.7093  
##                     3rd Qu.:   1818   3rd Qu.:0.9000  
##                     Max.   :4573953   Max.   :1.0000

Final formatting of the escapee data. This is used as a pressure layer.

# for each region/year: average the genetic escape probability for each taxa based on tonnes mariculture
genEscapes <- tonnes_esc %>%
  group_by(rgn_id, year) %>%
  summarize(genEscapes = weighted.mean(Escapees, tonnes, na.rm=TRUE))

# obtain corresponding gapfilling information for each region (average of gapfilled data, weighted by tonnes of mariculture).
genEscapes_gf <- tonnes_esc %>%
  mutate(gapfill = ifelse(gapfill_escapees=="none", 1, 0)) %>%
  group_by(rgn_id, year) %>%
  summarize(genEscapes = weighted.mean(gapfill, tonnes, na.rm=TRUE)) %>%
  ungroup() %>%
  filter(year==2015) %>%
  select(rgn_id, pressures.score=genEscapes) %>%
  mutate(pressures.score=ifelse(pressures.score=="NaN", NA, pressures.score)) %>%
  data.frame()
write.csv(genEscapes_gf, 'output/GenEsc_gf.csv', row.names=FALSE)

# create the escapee data layers:
    data <- genEscapes %>%
    select(rgn_id, year, pressure_score = genEscapes)
write.csv(data, 'output/GenEsc.csv', row.names=FALSE)  

old <- read.csv("../v2016/output/GenEsc_v2016.csv") %>%
  select(rgn_id, prs_score_old=pressure_score)

new <- read.csv("../v2017/output/GenEsc.csv") %>%
  filter(year == 2014)

full_join(old, new, by="rgn_id")
##     rgn_id prs_score_old year pressure_score
## 1        5     0.7964807 2014      0.7964807
## 2        6     0.7971429 2014      0.7971429
## 3        7            NA 2014             NA
## 4        8     0.7514532 2014      0.7604475
## 5        9            NA 2014             NA
## 6       10     0.7663669 2014      0.7663669
## 7       13     0.6735327 2014      0.6691120
## 8       14     0.7241200 2014      0.7241206
## 9       15     0.9411440 2014      0.9411440
## 10      16     0.3838975 2014      0.3838975
## 11      17     0.5582235 2014      0.5582235
## 12      18     0.5806985 2014      0.5806985
## 13      19     0.7663669 2014      0.7663669
## 14      20     0.3069893 2014      0.3069893
## 15      21     0.5008329 2014      0.5011867
## 16      24     0.6074649 2014      0.6074649
## 17      25     0.3925215 2014      0.3739447
## 18      29     0.7663669 2014      0.7663669
## 19      31            NA 2014             NA
## 20      32     0.7663669 2014      0.7663669
## 21      37     0.7657989 2014      0.7658158
## 22      40     0.9990298 2014      0.9990298
## 23      41     0.7547626 2014      0.7663669
## 24      42     0.9993118 2014      0.9993118
## 25      43            NA 2014             NA
## 26      45            NA 2014             NA
## 27      47            NA 2014             NA
## 28      48     0.5806985 2014      0.5806985
## 29      50     0.6230114 2014      0.6230114
## 30      51     0.7663669 2014      0.7663669
## 31      52     0.7797302 2014      0.7797302
## 32      53     0.5806985 2014      0.5806985
## 33      54     0.6648295 2014      0.6648295
## 34      61     0.7660007 2014      0.7660007
## 35      62     0.4204691 2014      0.4204691
## 36      65     0.7423177 2014      0.7423177
## 37      66     0.7090517 2014      0.7109449
## 38      67            NA 2014             NA
## 39      68     0.7663669 2014      0.7663669
## 40      70            NA 2014             NA
## 41      71     0.7423177 2014      0.7423177
## 42      72     0.7423177 2014      0.7423177
## 43      73     0.2176174 2014      0.2283597
## 44      75     0.1488866 2014      0.1488866
## 45      76     0.7779444 2014      0.7779444
## 46      78     0.5806985 2014      0.5806985
## 47      79     0.7663669 2014      0.7663669
## 48      80     0.9517867 2014      0.9517867
## 49      81     0.7654591 2014      0.7654591
## 50      82     0.7491413 2014      0.7491413
## 51      84     0.7655622 2014      0.7655622
## 52      95            NA 2014             NA
## 53     101     0.1221808 2014      0.1187643
## 54     102     0.5719148 2014      0.5719148
## 55     110            NA 2014             NA
## 56     111     0.7423177 2014      0.7423177
## 57     112     0.6239894 2014      0.6149838
## 58     115     0.6619284 2014      0.6619284
## 59     116            NA 2014             NA
## 60     129     0.9661499 2014      0.9661499
## 61     130     0.9054489 2014      0.9798884
## 62     131     1.0000000 2014      1.0000000
## 63     132     0.9883649 2014      0.9883649
## 64     133     0.5806985 2014      0.5806985
## 65     134     0.5842325 2014      0.5842325
## 66     135     0.9435785 2014      0.9435785
## 67     136     0.5806985 2014      0.5806985
## 68     137     1.0000000 2014      1.0000000
## 69     138     0.6762505 2014      0.6762505
## 70     139     0.1000354 2014      0.1000354
## 71     140     0.7663669 2014      0.7663669
## 72     141     1.0000000 2014      1.0000000
## 73     143     0.5387474 2014      0.5387474
## 74     147     0.7446706 2014      0.7446706
## 75     152            NA 2014             NA
## 76     153            NA 2014      0.7423177
## 77     155     0.7423177 2014      0.7423177
## 78     162     0.5056614 2014      0.5058548
## 79     163     0.5479550 2014      0.5479550
## 80     164     0.1000000 2014      0.1000000
## 81     166            NA 2014             NA
## 82     167     0.6527165 2014      0.6527165
## 83     168     0.5806985 2014      0.5806985
## 84     171     0.2615382 2014      0.2614700
## 85     172     0.5458015 2014      0.5458015
## 86     173            NA 2014             NA
## 87     174     0.7663669 2014      0.7663669
## 88     175     0.7903328 2014      0.7903328
## 89     176     0.9857486 2014      0.9857486
## 90     177     0.9790048 2014      0.9744183
## 91     179     0.5502637 2014      0.5499130
## 92     180     0.9915456 2014      0.9908737
## 93     181     0.7350241 2014      0.7350241
## 94     182     0.7751808 2014      0.7751800
## 95     183     0.8981931 2014      0.8981930
## 96     184     0.8127234 2014      0.8261301
## 97     186     0.7499655 2014      0.7499655
## 98     187     0.7644352 2014      0.7644352
## 99     188     0.7459432 2014      0.7455204
## 100    190            NA 2014             NA
## 101    191     0.5806985 2014      0.5806985
## 102    196            NA 2014             NA
## 103    202     0.6474867 2014      0.6476013
## 104    203     0.6767328 2014      0.6767328
## 105    204     0.6782781 2014      0.6782781
## 106    205     0.8498617 2014      0.8498617
## 107    206     0.7785543 2014      0.7790076
## 108    207     0.4795483 2014      0.5009622
## 109    208     0.7126076 2014      0.7128166
## 110    209     0.7106795 2014      0.7106828
## 111    210     0.8357228 2014      0.8356385
## 112    212     1.0000000 2014      1.0000000
## 113    214     0.6960988 2014      0.6960988
## 114    216     0.8360407 2014      0.8360407
## 115    218     0.5145825 2014      0.4974722
## 116    219     0.7423177 2014      0.7423177
## 117    222     0.3488323 2014      0.3488323
## 118    223     0.9862647 2014      0.9876013
## 119    224     0.3137570 2014      0.3137570
## 120    231     0.7354222 2014      0.7354222
## 121    232     0.7619943 2014      0.7619943
## 122    244            NA 2014             NA
## 123    245            NA 2014             NA
## 124    247     0.7958587 2014      0.7958587
## 125    250            NA 2014             NA
tmp_old <- read.csv("../v2016/raw/Truj_label_sust.csv")
tmp_new <- read.csv("../v2017/raw/Truj_label_sust.csv")

test <- full_join(tmp_new, tmp_old, by=c("country", "species_fao", "fao", "environment" ))
## Warning: Column `species_fao` joining factors with different levels,
## coercing to character vector