Assistive technologies need semantic information about the structures and expected behaviors of a document in order to convey appropriate information to persons with disabilities. This specification defines a [[!WAI-ARIA]] module of core roles, states and properties specific to web graphics. These semantics allow an author to express the logical structure of the graphic to assistive technologies. Assitive technologies could then enable semantic navigation and adapt styling and interactive features, to provide an optimal experience for the audience. These features complement the graphics and document structure elements defined by [[HTML5]] and [[SVG2]].

This document is part of the WAI-ARIA suite described in the WAI-ARIA Overview.

Please record issues on this specification through the Github W3C/aria issue tracker, using the prefix "Graphics" for any issue.

Introduction

WAI-ARIA is a technical specification that provides a framework to improve the accessibility and interoperability of web content and applications. It enables web browsers to map the accessibility semantics in web content to platform-specific accessibility APIs. This enables web content to be interoperable with platform assistive technologies, similar to native platform applications, without requiring authors to include platform dependencies.

This specification is a modular extension of WAI-ARIA designed to support graphics. The goals of this specification include:

This specification defines the core roles that would be used in all structured graphics or diagrams. Future work will expand on this framework to enable more detailed annotation of data-rich graphics such as charts or maps.

For a more detailed explanation of WAI-ARIA please refer to the WAI-ARIA Introduction and how it applies to Rich Internet Application Accessibility.

Target Audience

This specification defines a module of WAI-ARIA for graphics, including roles, states, properties and values. It impacts several audiences:

Each conformance requirement indicates the audience to which it applies.

User Agent Support

This module builds on the general User Agent support principles defined in [[!WAI-ARIA]] by also providing the ability for user agents to enhance the general user interface presented to readers.

Co-Evolution of WAI-ARIA and Host Languages

The Graphics WAI-ARIA module follows the model for co-evolution of WAI-ARIA and host languages defined in [[!WAI-ARIA]]. It is intended to augment semantics in supporting languages like [[HTML5]], [[!SVG2]] and EPUB, or to be used as an accessibility enhancement technology in other markup-based languages that do not explicitly include support for ARIA. It clarifies semantics to assistive technologies when authors create new types of objects, via style and script, that are not yet directly supported by the language of the page, because the invention of new types of objects is faster than standardized support for them appears in web languages.

It is not appropriate to create objects with style and script when the host language provides a semantic element for that type of objects. While WAI-ARIA can improve the accessibility of these objects, accessibility is best provided by allowing the user agent to handle the object natively. For example, it is not better to use a heading role on a div element than it is to use a native heading element, such as an h1.

It is expected that, over time, host languages will evolve to provide semantics for objects that currently can only be declared with this specification. This is natural and desirable, as one goal of WAI-ARIA is to help stimulate the emergence of more semantic and accessible markup. When native semantics for a given feature become available, it is appropriate for authors to use the native feature and stop using this module for that feature. Legacy content may continue to use the Graphics WAI-ARIA module, however, so the need for user agents to support it remains.

While specific features of this module may lose importance over time, the general possibility of the Graphics WAI-ARIA module to add semantics to web graphics or open web based standards, is expected to be a persistent need. Host languages may not implement all the semantics this module provides, and various host languages may implement different subsets of the features. New types of objects are continually being developed, and one goal of this specification is to provide a way to make such objects accessible, because authoring practices often advance faster than host language standards. In this way, this module and host languages both evolve together but at different rates.

Some host languages exist to create semantics for features other than the user interface. For example, SVG expresses the semantics behind production of graphical objects, not of user interface components that those objects may represent. Host languages such as these might, by design, not provide native semantics that map to this specification's features. In these cases, the Graphics WAI-ARIA module could be adopted as a long-term approach to add semantic information to these host languages.

Authoring Practices

Authoring Tools

Many of the requirements in the definitions of the WAI-ARIA and Graphics WAI-ARIA roles, states and properties can be checked automatically during the development process, similar to other quality control processes used for validating code. To assist authors who are creating graphics, these tools can compare the semantic structure of Graphics WAI-ARIA roles from the DOM to that defined in this specification and notify the author of errors or simply create templates that enforce that structure.

Testing Practices and Tools

The accessibility of interactive content cannot be confirmed by static checks alone. Developers of interactive content should test for device-independent access to widgets and applications, and should verify accessibility API access to all content and changes during user interaction.

Assistive Technologies

Programmatic access to accessibility semantics is essential for assistive technologies. For more information, refer to the Assistive Technologies section in [[!WAI-ARIA]].

This specification indicates whether a section is normative or informative. Classifying a section as normative or informative applies to the entire section. A statement "This section is normative" or "This section is informative" applies to all sub-sections of that section.

Normative sections provide requirements that authors, user agents and assistive technologies MUST follow for an implementation to conform to this specification.

Informative sections provide information useful to understanding the specification. Such sections may contain examples of recommended practice, but it is not required to follow such recommendations in order to conform to this specification.

Important Terms

Graphics Roles

This section defines additions to the WAI-ARIA role taxonomy and describes the characteristics and properties of all roles. See ARIA Roles for descriptions of the fields provided by this module.

Authors are given the ability to influence what is presented to assistive technologies and to influence navigation through the use of roles and properties. With graphics, there are many cases where presenting and navigating every element will make the graphic harder to understand and use. Authors may mark elements for exclusion from the semantic representation of the document (the accessibility tree) by assigning the role none or presentation. The element with this role should be treated transparently by assistive technologies, as if its children or text content were directly contained by its parent element.

In addition, certain roles, such as img or graphics-symbol, when assigned to a parent element, will cause all child DOM structure to be omitted from the accessibility tree. This is indicated by the "Children Presentational" value in the role characteristics table. Finally, the native semantics of the graphics language may also default to ignoring DOM structure that does not have semantic data attached; for SVG, this is defined in [[SVG-AAM]].

A role of none should never be used for interactive elements or those with WAI-ARIA states and properties.

Definition of Roles

Below is an alphabetical list of the WAI-ARIA roles defined in this specification. They would normally be used in combination with other roles defined in [[WAI-ARIA]] to annotate graphics within documents and rich internet applications.

Placeholder for compact list of roles


graphics-doc

A type of document in which the visual appearance or layout of content conveys meaning.

Similar to other document types, the graphics-doc role applies to the root element of a region of the page containing related information, where the user's primary interaction mode is expected to be browsing the document rather than controlling an application. The element with this role may be the root element of the document file, or of a nested structure within it.

The graphics-doc may be distinguished from similar roles as follows:

  • Relative to other documents, a graphics-doc is distinguished by the semantic importance of its visual (usually two-dimensional) representation. User agents and assistive technologies SHOULD take this into consideration when supporting navigation of the graphic. Accessibility technologies that re-format or re-style a document SHOULD NOT alter the layout of a graphics-doc except in ways that are consistent with the semantic roles and relationships of its content.

  • Relative to an img, a graphics-doc is distinguished by the structured nature of its content. Its child elements may have semantic meaning, and may include links or other interactive widgets.

  • Relative to a graphics-object, a graphics-doc is self-contained. Its meaning persists when separated from surrounding content. The element with the graphics-doc role defines the scope and context for interpretation of the child content.

In general, authors SHOULD use the graphics-doc role for structured graphics such as charts, maps, diagrams, technical drawing, blue prints and instructional graphics. However, if a single large graphic has discrete regions that may be safely re-arranged without sacrificing meaning, each of those regions SHOULD be a distinct graphics-doc. An alternative role (such as figure) may be used to group them together. One graphics-doc may also be nested inside another, for example a bar chart that is embedded in a map or a matrix of chart panels should have a role of graphics-doc. The nested document provides encapsulation; navigation between components of the inner and outer graphics should be explicit.

To support user agents and assistive technologies based on the ARIA 1.0 specification, authors may wish to include the document role as a fallback value, in the form role="graphics-doc document".

Future specifications may define more specific roles for particular types of graphical documents with special semantic structures. Those more specific roles would be subclasses of graphics-doc.

<!-- An SVG diagram of an electrical circuit -->
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" 
     width="400" height="200" viewBox="0 0 200 100"
     role="graphics-doc document" >
     <title>A simple circuit</title>
     <desc>A circuit with one source, one switch, and one load</desc>
     <style type="text/css">
        /* omitted */
     </style>
     <g id="battery-1" role="graphics-symbol img" 
        aria-roledescription="source" 
        aria-label="battery"
        aria-flowto="switch-1" 
        transform="translate(20,50)" >
        <path d="M-15,-5 h30 M-5,5 h10" />
     </g>
     <path class="wire" d="M20,45 V20 H90"/>
     <g id="switch-1" role="graphics-symbol img" 
        aria-roledescription="switch" 
        aria-label="single-pole switch"
        aria-flowto="lightbulb-1" >
        <path d="M90,20 L105,30" />
        <circle class="connection" cx="90" cy="20" r="2" />
        <circle class="connection" cx="110" cy="20" r="2" />
     </g>
     <!-- more wires and a light bulb --> 
</svg>


Characteristics:
Characteristic Value
Is Abstract:  
Superclass Role: document
Subclass Roles:  
Base Concept:  
Related Concepts:
Required Context Role:  
Required Owned Elements:
Required States and Properties:  
Supported States and Properties:  
Inherited States and Properties:  
Name From: author
Accessible Name Required: True
Inherits Name Required:
Children Presentational: False
Inherits Presentational:  
Implicit Value for Role:  

graphics-object

A section of a graphics-doc that represents a distinct object or sub-component with semantic meaning. A graphical object may itself have nested sub-components.

Container elements that instead represent a collection of disconnected objects should instead be given the group or list roles. Grouping elements that do not have semantic meaning and do not alter the semantic context provided by an ancestor SHOULD NOT be given a role, which may be explicitly indicated with the role none or presentation.

Unlike a graphics-doc, a graphics-object need not be self-contained, and it does not establish a new context for navigation. However, user agents and assistive technologies SHOULD provide a way for users, particularly non-visual users, to navigate the nested structure of objects in a hierarchical manner, similar to nested lists.

To support user agents and assistive technologies based on the ARIA 1.0 specification, authors may wish to include the group role as a fallback value, in the form role="graphics-object group".

The code that follows is a portion of the markup for a structured graphic. It includes SVG g grouping elements with various roles:

  • graphics-object for distinct objects, such as the house, its door, or roof.
  • group to group together the windows or the trees (multiple distinct objects) with a single label or description.
  • img for the background which is described as a whole.
  • none for elements that apply styles or transformations without having any semantic meaning.

Where a graphical object has multiple sub-components, the group role is provided as an explicit fallback.

<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"
     width="600" height="400" viewBox="0 0 600 400"
     role="graphics-doc document" xml:lang="en">
    <title>Home</title>
    <g role="img" aria-label="background">
        <desc>Blue sky, sunshine, and green grass</desc>
        <!-- The multiple parts of the background form a single image
             conveyed by that one description. -->
        <rect fill="lightSkyBlue" height="100%" width="100%" />
        <circle fill="yellow" stroke="gold" stroke-width="4"
                cx="0" cy="0" r="50" />
        <path fill="none" stroke="gold" stroke-width="3"
              d="..." />
        <rect fill="#6a2" y="300" width="100%" height="100" />
    </g>
    <g role="graphics-object group"
       aria-labelledby="house-label"
       transform="translate(100,325)">
        <desc>A two-storey brick house, drawn with basic shapes.
        </desc>
        <!-- The house has a number of details worth calling out,
             so it is a graphical object -->

        <rect fill="firebrick" stroke="darkRed"
              width="300" height="200" y="-200"
              role="none" /><!-- the walls of the house are 
                already described thoroughly,
                so no role is required -->

        <g role="graphics-object" aria-label="door"
           transform="translate(30,-90)">
            <desc>The brown door on the left side of the building
                has a window and a round doorknob</desc>
            <!-- The graphical object role allows for further
                 nested sub-components.
                 However, based on the default SVG API mappings,
                 these shapes, which have neither labels nor descriptions,
                 will be treated as presentation. -->
            <rect fill="darkKhaki" stroke="#632"
                  width="50" height="90"/>
            <rect fill="lightSteelBlue" stroke="#632" stroke-width="4" 
                  x="5" y="5" width="40" height="30" />
            <circle fill="gray" stroke="#444" stroke-width="0.7"
                    cx="10" cy="50" r="4" />
        </g>

        <g role="group" aria-label="windows"
           fill="lightSteelBlue" stroke="#632" stroke-width="6">
            <!-- The windows are distinct objects, 
                 grouped together with a common label -->
            <g role="none" transform="translate(0,-85)">
                <rect aria-label="first-floor window"
                      x="100" width="25" height="45">
                    <desc>A small window beside the door</desc>
                </rect>
                <path aria-label="first-floor living-room window"
                      d="M180,0h100v60h-100v-60z
                         m30,0v60 m40,0v-60">
                    <desc>A large three-pane window fills
                    the rest of the first floor</desc>
                </path>
            </g>
            <g role="none" transform="translate(0,-180)">
                <!-- more windows on the second floor -->
            </g>
        </g>
        <!-- more markup for the roof and chimney -->

        <text id="house-label"
              font-family="cursive" font-size="36px" 
              x="70" y="50">My House</text>
    </g>
    <!-- more markup for the trees -->
</svg>
Characteristics:
Characteristic Value
Is Abstract:  
Superclass Role: section
Subclass Roles:  
Base Concept:  
Related Concepts:
Required Context Role:  
Required Owned Elements:
Required States and Properties:  
Supported States and Properties:  
Inherited States and Properties:  
Name From:
  • author
  • contents
Accessible Name Required: False
Inherits Name Required:
Children Presentational: False
Inherits Presentational:  
Implicit Value for Role:  

graphics-symbol

A graphical object used to convey a simple meaning or category, where the meaning is more important than the particular visual appearance. It may be a component of a larger structured graphic such as a chart or map. The symbol itself is an atomic object; children are presentational.

When used as part of a structured symbolic language, the aria-roledescription property (introduced in ARIA 1.1 [[WAI-ARIA]]) can be used to name the symbol type separately from the name and description for the particular instance of the symbol.

To support user agents and assistive technologies based on the ARIA 1.0 specification, authors may wish to include the img role as a fallback value, in the form role="graphics-symbol img", if that is not already the default semantic role for the element.

<!-- Within an HTML document listing a restaurant menu -->
<h2>Appetizers</h2>
<ul>
    <li> Spinach Salad with Strawberry & Almonds
        <img role="graphics-symbol" title="Vegetarian" src="../assets/leaf.svg" />
        <img role="graphics-symbol" title="Contains Nuts" src="../assets/peanut.svg" />
    </li>
    <li> Chicken Satay with Peanut Sauce
        <img role="graphics-symbol" title="Contains Nuts" src="../assets/peanut.svg" />
    </li>
    <!-- … -->
</ul>
<!-- Within an SVG diagram of an electrical circuit -->
<g id="lightbulb-1" role="graphics-symbol img" 
   aria-roledescription="load" 
   aria-label="lightbulb"
   aria-describedby="lightbulb-1-label"
   aria-flowto="battery-1" 
   transform="translate(180,50)">
    <text id="lightbulb-1-label"
        x="-15" dy="0.5ex" text-anchor="end" >10W</text>
    <circle r="10" />
    <path d="M0,-10 C0,8 5,8 5,0 C5,-8 0,-8 0,10" />
</g>



<!-- Within an architectural blueprint-style SVG diagram -->
<g role="graphics-symbol img">
    <title>Door</title>
    <desc>on West side of South wall</desc>
    <line stroke-width="8" stroke="white" 
          x1="50" y1="275" x2="150" y2="275"/>
    <line stroke-width="4" stroke="#444" 
          x1="50" y1="275" x2="125" y2="225"/>        
</g>
<!-- … -->
<use xlink:href="#outlet" role="graphics-symbol img" 
     x="5" y="130" width="40" height="40">
    <title>Electrical outlet</title>
    <desc>at center of West wall</desc>
</use>



Characteristics:
Characteristic Value
Is Abstract:  
Superclass Role: graphics-object
Subclass Roles:  
Base Concept:  
Related Concepts:
Required Context Role:  
Required Owned Elements:
Required States and Properties:  
Supported States and Properties:  
Inherited States and Properties:  
Name From: author
Accessible Name Required: True
Inherits Name Required:
Children Presentational: True
Inherits Presentational:  
Implicit Value for Role:  

Other Roles for Graphics

The following core ARIA roles, defined in [[WAI-ARIA]], are also relevant for annotating graphics:

The following examples demonstrate appropriate use of img, figure, and graphics-doc in a document.

Within an HTML 5 document, an inline SVG may sometimes represent an atomic img. If the graphics form part of the natural reading flow of the text, then this role is sufficient, as in the first example:

<p>A repeating SVG gradient is defined using the
    <code>spreadMethod</code> attribute.  
    A value of <code>repeat</code> causes the color stops
    to repeat in the same order, from beginning to end:</p>
<svg class="inline-example" role="img">
    <title>A repeating linear gradient</title>
    <desc>The gradient starts dark, slowly shifting to light, 
        then quickly dark again.  This pattern repeats four
        times left to right, each time brightening across a large
        region and then getting dark within a short space.
    </desc>
    <linearGradient id="repeat" x2="25%" spreadMethod="repeat">
        <stop offset="0"     stop-color="black" />
        <stop offset="0.8" stop-color="white" />
        <stop offset="1"     stop-color="black" />
    </linearGradient>
    <rect width="100%" height="100%" fill="url(#repeat)" />
</svg>

The following example provides the same content, but now structured as a figure that may be re-positioned separately from the flow of paragraph text.

<figure id="fig1" role="figure region">
    <svg id="fig1A" class="nested-figure" role="figure"
         aria-labelledby="fig1-caption, fig1A-caption">
        <!-- markup omitted-->
    </svg>
    <svg id="fig1B" class="nested-figure" role="figure"
         aria-labelledby="fig1-caption, fig1B-caption">
        <linearGradient id="reflect" spreadMethod="reflect"
                        xlink:href="#repeat" />
        <text id="fig1B-caption" class="caption" dy="1em"
              >b) spreadMethod="reflect"</text>
        <rect role="img"
              y="25%" width="100%" height="75%" fill="url(#reflect)" >
            <title>A reflecting linear gradient</title>
            <desc>The gradient again starts dark, slowly shifting to light, 
              then quickly dark again.  However, the next repeat shifts
              quickly to the light, then slowly back dark.  
              The original pattern is then repeated, followed by the reflected
              version again.
            </desc>
        </rect>
    </svg>
    <figcaption id="fig1-caption"
                >Figure 1: Repeating SVG gradients</figcaption>
</figure>

Finally, the last version uses a graphics-doc to include complex annotations on the graphic, which is still contained within a figure element. The two sections of the graphic are graphics-object elements, while the annotations have individual labels and descriptions.

<figure id="fig1" role="figure region">
    <svg role="graphics-doc">
        <title>Repeating versus reflecting linear gradients</title>
        <desc>
            The graphic shows two gradient patterns,
            annotated with text labels and arrows.
            Both gradients use the same series of color stops,
            starting dark, slowly shifting to light, 
            then quickly dark again.
            This cycle covers one-quarter of the width of the graphic,
            starting on the left.
            The two gradients differ in their repeat cycles.
        </desc>
        <defs>
            <!-- markup omitted -->
        </defs>
        <g role="graphics-object" aria-labelledby="repeat-label">
            <!-- markup omitted -->
        </g>            
        <g role="graphics-object" aria-labelledby="reflect-label">
            <desc>
                The gradient stretches across the bottom half of 
                the graphic.
                Each cycle of the gradient alternates direction,
                left-to-right then right-to-left,
                as do the arrows that emphasize the pattern.
            </desc>
            <rect y="50%" width="100%" height="50%" fill="url(#reflect)" />
            </rect>
            <use y="70%" xlink:href="#gradient-vector" >
                <title>1st cycle</title>
                <desc>left-to-right arrow, starting from x="0"</desc>
            </use>
            <use y="70%" x="-50%" transform="scale(-1,1)"
                 xlink:href="#gradient-vector" >
                <title>2nd cycle, reflected</title>
                <desc>right-to-left arrow, ending at x="25%"</desc>
            </use>
            <use y="70%" x="50%" xlink:href="#gradient-vector" >
                <title>3rd cycle</title>
                <desc>left-to-right arrow, starting from x="50%"</desc>
            </use>
            <use y="70%" x="-100%" transform="scale(-1,1)"
                 xlink:href="#gradient-vector" >
                <title>4th cycle, reflected</title>
                <desc>right-to-left arrow, ending at x="75%"</desc>
            </use>
            <text id="reflect-label" class="overlay-text" 
                  aria-label="spreadMethod='reflect'"
                  dy="-0.2em" dx="-0.2em" x="100%" y="100%"
                  >reflect</text>
        </g>
    </svg>
    <figcaption>Figure 1: spreadMethod options for
        repeating SVG gradients</figcaption>
</figure>
    

Should we expand on the following example to demonstrate how canvas hit regions create a graphical document?

<!-- Within the fallback DOM dynamically constructed
     for an HTML 5 canvas game,
     elements may represent the different images
     that create the composite graphic -->
<canvas role="graphics-doc">
    <p id="scene-desc" role="img" 
       aria-label="The Dungeon"
       aria-describedby="scene-desc">
       The door opens into a long hallway.
       Every few steps on either side are barred doors.
       Moisture drips from the stone walls.
    </p>
    <p id="grue-1" role="img"
       aria-label="Grue"
       aria-describedby="grue-1">
       An amorphous and poorly defined, but unmistakably sinister,
       creature blocks the passage.
   </p>
   <!-- more DOM elements representing game controls -->
</canvas>

States and Properties

WAI-ARIA provides a collection of accessibility state and properties which are used to support platform accessibility APIs on various operating system platforms. Assistive technologies may access this information through an exposed user agent DOM or through a mapping to the platform accessibility API. When combined with roles, the user agent can supply the assistive technologies with user interface information to convey to the user at any time. Changes in states or properties will result in a notification to assistive technologies, which could alert the user that a change has occurred.

Schemata

The HTML Working Group has incorporated the WAI-ARIA attributes into HTML 5. Official support for WAI-ARIA in HTML is provided in that specification.

Validation support for the roles defined in this module will be added once the specification reaches recommendation.

For information on incorporating WAI-ARIA into other grammars, refer to Appendix A of [[!WAI-ARIA]]

Review whether any additional schemata are necessary for this module.

Change Log

A detailed history of changes committed is available from the github repository for this document. When drafts of this document begin to stabilise, human-readable change logs will be incorporated.

WAI-ARIA Role, State, and Property Quick Reference

The following table provides a quick reference to the supported states and properties for all WAI-ARIA roles that may be used in markup.

In addition to the states and properties shown in the table, the following global states and properties are supported on all roles.

Placeholder for global states and properties

Placeholder for quick reference table

Acknowledgments

The following people contributed to the development of this document.

Participants active in the SVG accessibility task force at the time of publication

  • Amelia Bellamy-Royds (Invited expert)
  • Fred Esch (IBM Corporation)
  • Charles McCathieNevile (Yandex)
  • Charu Pandhi (IBM Corporation)
  • Doug Schepers (W3C Staff)
  • Richard Schwerdtfeger (IBM Corporation)
  • Léonie Watson (The Paciello Group)
  • Jason White (Educational Testing Service)

Participants active in the PFWG at the time of publication

  • Christy Blew (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign)
  • David Bolter (Mozilla Foundation)
  • Michael Cooper (W3C/MIT)
  • James Craig (Apple Inc.)
  • Joanmarie Diggs (Igalia)
  • Fred Esch (IBM Corporation)
  • Steve Faulkner (The Paciello Group)
  • John Foliot (Invited Expert)
  • Christopher Gallelo (Microsoft Corporation)
  • Bryan Garaventa (SSB BART Group)
  • Scott González (JQuery Foundation)
  • Billy Gregory (The Paciello Group)
  • Karl Groves (The Paciello Group)
  • Jon Gunderson (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign)
  • Birkir Gunnarsson (Deque Systems, Inc.)
  • Markus Gylling (DAISY Consortium)
  • Mona Heath (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign)
  • Susann Keohane (IBM Corporation)
  • Matthew King (IBM Corporation)
  • Jason Kiss (Department of Internal Affairs, New Zealand Government)
  • Dominic Mazzoni (Google, Inc.)
  • Shane McCarron (Invited Expert, Aptest)
  • Charles McCathieNevile (Yandex)
  • Mary Jo Mueller (IBM Corporation)
  • James Nurthen (Oracle Corporation)
  • Janina Sajka (Invited Expert, The Linux Foundation)
  • Joseph Scheuhammer (Invited Expert, Inclusive Design Research Centre, OCAD University)
  • Stefan Schnabel (SAP AG)
  • Richard Schwerdtfeger (IBM Corporation)
  • Lisa Seeman (Invited Expert)
  • Cynthia Shelly (Microsoft Corporation)
  • Alexander Surkov (Mozilla Foundation)
  • Léonie Watson (The Paciello Group)
  • Jason White (Educational Testing Service)
  • Marco Zehe (Mozilla Foundation)
  • Gottfried Zimmermann (Invited Expert, Access Technologies Group)